Reprint from www.familysecuritymatters.org:
Harvard- and Oxford-educated Benazir Bhutto, who twice served Pakistan as its Prime Minister, was assassinated yesterday by Taliban and al Qaeda supporters in a spectacularly violent act in Rawalpindi, Pakistan. This act threw the country into a spasm of violence on the eve of national elections planned for January 8th. The agony of Pakistan splattered across the small screen was palpable, as was the transformation of Bhutto into a martyr for democracy in the world’s media. That was reflected in comments from leaders in the US, France, India, Russia and even Iran.
The lurking danger in Pakistan is that the former Prime Minister, Nawaz Sharif, who was also the subject of a failed assassination attempt, has some skeletons in his closet. He tried to befriend bin Laden as a means of co-opting Al Qaeda. Further, he is allied with Islamist elements in the Pakistani government intelligence service, the ISI, which might facilitate a Taliban-like takeover. It was the late Ms. Bhutto who in recent correspondence accused the ISI of trying to assassinate her.
The prospect of a Taliban-like takeover is daunting. Pakistan is acknowledged to have 60 nuclear heads, developed by the infamous Dr. A.Q. Khan, presently under house arrest. He also facilitated transfer of key nuclear technology to Iran from Pakistan. The fear is that the only bastion of opposition to the Islamists may collapse the largely secular Army of Pakistan. Without that bastion, the country might become another Islamic Republic akin to that in Shia-dominated Iran.
We saw the same scenario play out in Lebanon in 1975 when the volatile situation ended with the breaking of the Lebanese army into half, along sectarian lines. The Muslims took their military equipment and bases and formed their own army, calling it the Lebanese Arabic Army. That plunged Lebanon into a 15 year civil war giving terrorist organizations and supporters around the world a base of operations to launch terrorist attacks throughout the world.
The danger here is the possibility of this happening in Pakistan where you have the foreign element of the Taliban and Al-Qaeda fighters who came from around the Islamic world to fight for the cause. The difference here is that Pakistan has nukes and those nukes, if fallen into the wrong hands, would prove to be a disaster threatening the civilized world and Western style democracies across the globe.
Bhutto’s death should also be a warning to the Western world to make sure more attention is paid to those allies of Western democracies who are running for leadership in the Islamic world and have a strong following. After all, if our goal is to establish more moderate Islamic countries, we must insure the safety and security of those running for government positions who vow to fight and defeat the same terrorists we are trying to defeat.
Benazir Bhutto is the epitome of the role model we want in the Islamic world: a woman with a high level education from the West who could inspire thousands of women and men in the Islamic world to educate and help women’s causes. Today, according to the UN report on human development in the 21st century, two thirds of women in the Muslim world cannot read nor write. Benazir Bhutto was the perfect example of an honorable Muslim woman, also. She was a proud Muslim who practiced her faith publicly but believed strongly in the separation between religion and government, a very rare stand in the Islamic world.
We must insure that Musharraf is supported in his strong grip over the radicals in Pakistan. We also must send a very strong signal to the majority moderates in Pakistan that the United States wants to work with them to insure safety and stability in the country. In 1979, former President Carter and his NSC staff began dialogues with Khomeini as a means of bringing “democracy” to an Iran under the yoke of the late Shah who sat on the Peacock Throne. Instead, all that did was bring about the Islamic Republic of Iran and confrontation between Shia extremists, the US and its ally Israel through proxies in Lebanon, Iraq and, ironically the Taliban in Afghanistan. This is the last thing we want happening in Pakistan.
Despite our desire to bring democracy into the Islamic World, it hasn’t worked. The sectarian violence we have seen in Iraq, Lebanon, Pakistan, Palestine, Jordan and Egypt is ironically emboldened by Western concepts of democracy. In the Muslim world they don’t need it. They have the community of believers, the ummah and the mandate of strict Shar-ia Islamic law to establish a worldwide Caliphate with a strong Emir. The Jihad doctrine is incompatible with Western democracy. In Pakistan, if the US government makes the mistake of pushing the ideal of democracy over security, the untoward consequence could be the rise of an Islamic Republic under the Taliban and Al Qaeda. Even the late Benazir Bhutto, the only woman elected a political leader in a Muslim country, would have found that prospect untenable.
At this time in our war against radical Islam throughout the world we must take extreme caution to minimize mistakes. The world has become one global community where news events in one nation affect the world economy and stock markets. As soon as the news of Bhutto hit the airwaves the stock markets around the world started to fall. The price of oil and gold soared in world markets as the dollar took a dive. The fear of nuclear bombs falling in the wrong hands as well as the instability in such a volatile part of the world sent shivers across the world’s media.
Our only comfort when it comes to the nukes is the special $100 million US grant program to Pakistan to protect the nukes since 911. We can only hope that our plans A, B and C are in place to handle any sudden unexpected turn of events.
Should the upcoming national election occur in Pakistan on January 8th, then perhaps President Bush and Secretary Rice might applaud Pakistani political and human rights efforts. After all, the Pakistani military has taken serious casualties in the battles against Taliban forces in its Northwest Frontier provinces and in the Valley of Swat.
The late Benazir Bhutto may be an instant martyr to her people and a fallen fighter for democracy in the region. The realities are that she was killed in a Taliban/Al Qaeda attack. The other reality was that she was ejected as Prime Minister, during her second term in 1996, on corruption charges. She chose to remain in exile until her fateful return at the urging of the US government. Whatever transpires, our priority should be a pragmatic one to support the largely secular Military in Pakistan as a bulwark against the sudden rise of an Islamic Republic that could unnerve the region, especially the neighboring Republic of India.

































